Having represented many clients with selling their businesses, raising capital, or entering into joint ventures, the issue of Non-Disclosure Agreements (“NDA”) always arises. The primary focus of clients is on ensuring that the NDA is as secure as possible and often such that no reasonable party would agree to it. Thus, I find my job is to help them understand what is commercially reasonable, and more importantly, to work with them to understand who is the other party executing the NDA.
Most sales of small companies these days in the US are to Private Equity Groups, and so many people become complacent about understanding who the other party is. If the other party is not someone that is known, far more work needs to be done to understand:
-
Who is the other party is;
-
Where are they located;
-
What you each have; and
-
How much you share.
Failure to do this potentially exposes you to the “Achilles Heel” of the NDA.
First of all, if there is a breach of the NDA, most NDAs allow for injunctive relief, which is obtainable in the US, so damage within the US may be limited. However, if you want more than injunctive relief in the US, the areas of concerns are:
Who?
Who is the company? A Fortune 500 Company, some sizeable foreign company that you have never heard of, but there is information on or some company that for which there is no information? Many people don’t look at who is executing the agreement if they believe the person they are dealing with is with XYZ Corporation that they know.
However, if the entity executing the NDA is a single purpose subsidiary of XYZ, does it have any capital? Is XYZ a party to the transaction? Finally, there are cases in some developing markets, especially China, where government entities own many companies, i.e., the People’s Liberation Army owns many Chinese businesses, and thus for all practical purposes, these are immune from any claims.
Recently I came across a situation where ABC, a US company, found that their confidential information was being used against them by Z, a subsidiary of Company Y in China. ABC had executed an NDA with X, a Singaporean special purpose subsidiary of Y with no assets. Also, there was a Letter of Intent with T, a US subsidiary of Y, which also had no assets. As a result, there were no identifiable assets to go against, and to win in China would be hard.
Where?
If the NDA is with a non-US company, you may have issues in bringing a claim. While the NDA may provide that the venue and choice of law are your home state, the other party has to be served and appeared in federal or that state’s court. If the other party is not in the US, it may be challenging to serve even them because they may not exist, or the address/agent provided doesn’t exist. If you can’t serve them, a proceeding may be complicated.
Assuming you serve them, and they fail to appear, you should win in court. However, even if you do, you may not be able to enforce any claims because their courts will not recognize the US court’s decision. In some countries I have dealt with, judges have not recognized contractual agreements because “times have changed.” Not all countries have a judicial system like ours with precedent and some predictability.
Even if governmental agencies don’t own these companies, in some countries, if well-connected business people and politicians do, that may have the same result. Bringing any claims against a company owned by such a businessman or politician may result in you, your company, or employees being harassed or imprisoned on some charge in these countries, i.e., China and Russia.
How Much Has Each Party?
1. What Assets do They Have?
If it is a single purpose entity with no assets, even if you bring the claim and win, there are no assets to pay monetary damages. Injunctive relief is all you have. That may not fix any damage done to your brand or pay for all the litigation. Even if they have assets, if there are superior claims on those assets, i.e., bank liens, that can rank above your claim, you could win but still receive no monetary damages.
Finally, if they are a large company with deep pockets, they may fight you in court with a full army of in-house and third-party lawyers. Besides, even if they lose, they may be willing to fight through many appeals. The purpose is to wear down a smaller company just by having more resources.
2. What Assets do You Have?
While many client’s businesses are profitable and have value, the company may not have the financial wherewithal to fund litigation, especially international litigation. To fight a company in the US that is determined to protect its image on an NDA could cost $0.5MM and more. Many small companies don’t have that amount of excess cash to put towards litigation. Besides, not only is there the cost of the lawsuit but the disruption to the business. Discovery, depositions, etc. can absorb large amounts of time and resources from a small company causing it to lose its way or position and thus value.
3. What Loss have You Experienced?
Raising this issue causes an angry response from many clients? The value of the business, which they may think, is very high, has now suffered a loss in value. As with all litigation, you must demonstrate the damage. If there is a $XMM offer from a buyer who immediately reduces the offer to $YMM quickly on finding out about the breach, then the loss is $(X – Y)MM. However, in all other situations proving the quantum of the damage is much more complicated. Experts are required to determine your loss, which also increases the costs of litigation. The other side will also have their experts to prove no loss in value and show where your experts are wrong. Finally, the winner and amount of the win are never guaranteed when walking into a court, no matter what you think.
How Much Information Do You Share
While you are going to discuss your business, the products, customers, and opportunities, I think it is advisable to be economical with some of that information. Give the other party enough for them to make a decision and be interested. However, many owners are so proud and excited about their business, with good reason; they cannot help themselves from disclosing how they do everything. While some of this information may be a trade secret, it may not have been protected as such or may be more difficult to claim such in litigation. If the other party knows how you do everything, they may decide they can duplicate your business using your processes but not using your technology or approaching your customers. They do this; it may be much hard to identify and protect.
Thus, be careful with your NDAs by knowing:
-
Who you are dealing with;
-
Where are they located;
-
What they have;
-
Know what you can do if they breach; and
-
Let your advisor help you control the information flow.
© 2015 Marc Borrelli All Rights Reserved
Recent Posts
Align and Thrive: The Importance of Organizational Alignment and Agility
Discover the importance of organizational alignment and agility in this blog post. Learn how establishing a strong CORE and building a strategy around it can lead to sustainable growth and success. Find out how alignment and agility empower your organization to thrive in an ever-changing business landscape.
How to Achieve Smart Time Management: 10 Tips for Busy Professionals
When you are a busy professional running your own business, it can often feel like there aren’t enough hours in the day to accomplish everything. Being strategic with your time is the best (and possibly the only) way to achieve all of your daily tasks. If you are...
5 Strategic Leadership Skills Every Manager Needs
So often, people view leadership as a talent: you’re either born with this quality or you’re not. However, this is not always the case! In reality, good leadership is made up of skills, and anyone can learn how to improve. Some people may pick up leadership attributes...
How the Sellability Score is Calculated: The Ultimate Guide
Do you have questions about how to calculate your business’s sellability score? Whether you’re looking to sell your business in the near future or years from now, understanding your sellability score will help you thrive. The sellability score identifies the...
The Top 5 Benefits of the Entrepreneurial Operating System
As an entrepreneur running your own business, you know there are bumps in the road and struggles that both you and your business will face over time. However, with the right people and tools at your disposal, you can anticipate what’s coming, plan for it, and continue...
5 Ways to Use Email Automation to Boost Traffic
Every single business in the world wants to evolve and grow. This will happen using a variety of techniques and strategies. In 2022, digital marketing is more than a household name, and most companies will adopt at least a few ideas when long-term planning and coming...
6 Questions To Ask A Potential Business Coach Before Hiring Them
Many entrepreneurs consider executive business coaching when they start struggling on their professional path. A small business coach is an experienced professional mentor who educates, supports, and motivates entrepreneurs. They will listen to your concerns, assess...
3 Ways Proper Long Term Strategic Planning Helps Your Business
Dreams turn into goals when they have a foundation of long-term strategic planning supporting them. They become reality when the ensuing strategic implementation plan is executed properly. With Kaizen Solutions as their strategic planning consultant, small and...
What is a Peer Group, and How Can it Improve Your Career?
If you are a CEO or key executive who has come to a crossroads or crisis in your career, you'll gain valuable insights and solutions from a peer group connection more than anywhere else. But what is a peer group, and how can that statement be made with so much...
Profit and Revenue are Lousy Core Values
As I mentioned last week, I am down with COVID and tired, so spending more time reading rather than working. I read Bill Browder's Freezing Order this weekend, and I highly recommend it. However, at the end of the book, Browder says that oligarchs, autocrats, and...
I am a student of BAK College. The recent paper competition gave me a lot of headaches, and I checked a lot of information. Finally, after reading your article, it suddenly dawned on me that I can still have such an idea. grateful. But I still have some questions, hope you can help me.
Reading your article helped me a lot and I agree with you. But I still have some doubts, can you clarify for me? I’ll keep an eye out for your answers.
js混淆 hello my website is js混淆
talasha hello my website is talasha
aj88461 hello my website is aj88461
100ml hello my website is 100ml
noe row hello my website is noe row
Y8 Lego hello my website is Y8 Lego
yttmps hello my website is yttmps
kg10a7s hello my website is kg10a7s
skaylar hello my website is skaylar
http://withoutprescription.guru/# best non prescription ed pills
http://withoutprescription.guru/# buy prescription drugs from india
reputable canadian pharmacy [url=http://canadapharm.top/#]Prescription Drugs from Canada[/url] canadian pharmacy 365
viagra without a doctor prescription: non prescription ed drugs – buy prescription drugs online
pharmacy website india: buy prescription drugs from india – reputable indian pharmacies
amoxicillin 500mg without prescription: cost of amoxicillin 875 mg – purchase amoxicillin online
https://withoutprescription.guru/# sildenafil without a doctor’s prescription
http://withoutprescription.guru/# prescription drugs canada buy online
treatment for ed [url=http://edpills.icu/#]treatments for ed[/url] best ed medication
india online pharmacy: india pharmacy – buy prescription drugs from india
https://mexicopharm.shop/# mexico drug stores pharmacies
prednisone 40 mg price: prednisone 50 mg prices – buying prednisone from canada
https://edpills.icu/# herbal ed treatment
canadian mail order pharmacy [url=http://canadapharm.top/#]recommended canadian pharmacies[/url] canada drugstore pharmacy rx
cheapest online pharmacy india: п»їlegitimate online pharmacies india – reputable indian online pharmacy
cheap kamagra [url=http://kamagra.team/#]buy kamagra online usa[/url] buy Kamagra
sildenafil price 100mg: sildenafil from india – can i buy sildenafil over the counter in canada
best medication for ed: erectile dysfunction pills – erectile dysfunction medicines
https://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil online prescription
http://tadalafil.trade/# where to buy tadalafil in singapore
compare ed drugs [url=https://edpills.monster/#]cheap ed drugs[/url] ed remedies
buy erection pills: erectile dysfunction pills – cheapest ed pills online
http://levitra.icu/# Levitra online USA fast
Kamagra 100mg price [url=https://kamagra.team/#]cheap kamagra[/url] sildenafil oral jelly 100mg kamagra
best ed treatment: online ed pills – best ed pills non prescription
Levitra 20 mg for sale: Cheap Levitra online – buy Levitra over the counter
http://levitra.icu/# Cheap Levitra online
http://tadalafil.trade/# tadalafil online in india
ed treatment review [url=http://edpills.monster/#]natural ed medications[/url] ed treatment review
sildenafil generic without prescription: sildenafil buy cheap – sildenafil sale uk
http://sildenafil.win/# sildenafil 100mg price online
cheapest ed pills [url=http://edpills.monster/#]treatments for ed[/url] ed medications list
lisinopril 2.5 cost: Lisinopril 10 mg Tablet buy online – prinivil drug
https://doxycycline.forum/# buy doxycycline 100mg cheap
doxycycline 300 mg [url=http://doxycycline.forum/#]Buy doxycycline 100mg[/url] doxycycline cost uk
doxycycline price singapore: Buy doxycycline hyclate – buy doxycycline monohydrate
lisinopril generic drug: buy lisinopril online – where can i order lisinopril online
https://azithromycin.bar/# purchase zithromax z-pak
Thank you very much for sharing, I learned a lot from your article. Very cool. Thanks. nimabi
where can i buy doxycycline over the counter [url=https://doxycycline.forum/#]Buy doxycycline hyclate[/url] doxycycline tablets in india
lisinopril 20 mg cost: lisinopril 5mg cost – lisinopril india
http://azithromycin.bar/# generic zithromax over the counter
cipro ciprofloxacin: buy ciprofloxacin over the counter – ciprofloxacin mail online
lisinopril 40 mg cost [url=http://lisinopril.auction/#]Lisinopril 10 mg Tablet buy online[/url] prinivil
buy ciprofloxacin over the counter: buy ciprofloxacin over the counter – ciprofloxacin generic price
https://ciprofloxacin.men/# buy cipro online
buy cheap doxycycline uk [url=http://doxycycline.forum/#]doxycycline without a prescription[/url] buy doxycycline online usa
lisinopril without an rx: buy prinivil online – price of lisinopril
buy generic ciprofloxacin: cipro online no prescription in the usa – buy cipro online without prescription
https://ciprofloxacin.men/# buy cipro online canada
zithromax pill [url=http://azithromycin.bar/#]zithromax over the counter[/url] zithromax 500mg price in india
buy doxycycline over the counter: Buy doxycycline for chlamydia – doxycycline 50 medicine
http://amoxicillin.best/# buy amoxicillin online without prescription
mexico drug stores pharmacies: mexico pharmacy – mexico drug stores pharmacies
http://canadiandrugs.store/# canadian online pharmacy reviews
prescription drug pricing: online pharmacy usa – drugstore online shopping
top 10 online pharmacy in india [url=https://indiapharmacy.site/#]india pharmacy mail order[/url] india online pharmacy
buy drugs online: buy medication online – drug canada
https://ordermedicationonline.pro/# canada pharmacies top best
indian pharmacy online: buy medicines online in india – online pharmacy india
buying prescription drugs in mexico: mexican pharmaceuticals online – mexico pharmacies prescription drugs
https://indiapharmacy.site/# top online pharmacy india
canadian online pharmacy reviews [url=http://canadiandrugs.store/#]legal canadian pharmacy online[/url] safe reliable canadian pharmacy
paxlovid cost without insurance: paxlovid pharmacy – Paxlovid over the counter
http://gabapentin.life/# neurontin medicine
https://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid india
order ventolin online uk [url=https://claritin.icu/#]buy Ventolin inhaler[/url] ventolin inhaler without prescription
neurontin 400mg: buy gabapentin online – neurontin cap 300mg price
https://claritin.icu/# ventolin 95mcg
paxlovid buy: buy paxlovid – paxlovid india
https://claritin.icu/# buy ventolin pills online
paxlovid covid https://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid buy
can i get clomid pills: Buy Clomid Online Without Prescription – where to buy cheap clomid no prescription
https://claritin.icu/# buy ventolin canada
http://wellbutrin.rest/# wellbutrin canadian pharmacy
ventolin pharmacy uk: buy ventolin over the counter nz – where to buy ventolin generic
https://clomid.club/# can you get cheap clomid without a prescription
purchase wellbutrin sr: Wellbutrin prescription – wellbutrin 75 mg cost
http://paxlovid.club/# paxlovid pill
acquisto farmaci con ricetta: avanafil – farmacia online
farmacia online migliore: cialis prezzo – comprare farmaci online all’estero
https://farmaciait.pro/# farmacie online sicure
farmaci senza ricetta elenco [url=https://kamagrait.club/#]kamagra gel[/url] farmacie online sicure
farmacie on line spedizione gratuita: kamagra gel – migliori farmacie online 2023
farmacie on line spedizione gratuita: Dove acquistare Cialis online sicuro – top farmacia online
farmacie on line spedizione gratuita: Farmacie a milano che vendono cialis senza ricetta – acquisto farmaci con ricetta
farmacia online migliore: farmacia online miglior prezzo – farmacie online affidabili
https://kamagrait.club/# migliori farmacie online 2023
farmacia online miglior prezzo: Avanafil farmaco – top farmacia online
comprare farmaci online con ricetta: avanafil – farmacia online più conveniente
farmacia online più conveniente: cialis generico – top farmacia online
acquistare farmaci senza ricetta: farmacia online miglior prezzo – comprare farmaci online all’estero
farmacia online migliore: kamagra gold – farmacia online senza ricetta
cerco viagra a buon prezzo: viagra online siti sicuri – viagra online consegna rapida
farmacie online autorizzate elenco [url=https://avanafilit.icu/#]avanafil generico[/url] comprare farmaci online all’estero