Most hiring is wrong; businesses have a 54 percent success rate
How successful are we at recruitment? According to the Harvard Business Review, 80 percent of employee turnover stems from bad hiring decisions. A Brandon-Hall research brief found 95 percent of employers surveyed admitted to making hiring mistakes by recruiting the wrong people each year.
According to a 2015 Leadership IQ study, 46 percent of hires are considered failures by the time they reach the 18-month mark. A 54% success rate! Would you accept that from any other area of your business? Not only do we have a 54% success rate, but the costs of a bad hire are huge. Google searches give estimates as follows:
-
The cost of a bad hire can reach up to 30% of the employee’s first-year earnings — US Department of Labor
-
Bad hires cost $240,000 in expenses related to hiring, compensation, and retention — The Undercover Recruiter
-
74% of companies who admit they’ve hired the wrong person for a position lost an average of $14,900 for each lousy hire — CareerBuilder
Since all businesses need employees, why are businesses bad at it? Why do they tolerate this inferior performance, as they all have to face the repercussions of poor hires?
Every business leader understands the negative consequences of a bad hire. Hiring a bad fit for your team can disrupt team morale, decreased productivity, and hurt customer service. Also, there are those terrible hires, which are great, but the company puts them off so much they leave.
But the most successful businesses have what it takes to ensure a bad hire doesn’t derail their teams.
Disposable Employees
Part of the issue, in my opinion, is that the disposable society has migrated to employees. We tolerate lousy hiring, as we believe we can easily replace them with better employees if they don’t work out. However, this assumption is flawed and is another example of hubris.
Because of this faulty assumption, we don’t bother to put in place processes for recruiting, interviewing, and on-boarding to ensure that we are not undertaking lousy hiring practices.
Many will say, but we have processes, and indeed, you do. However, are they useful? It goes to your culture. If your firm has a culture of continuous improvement, then you be continuously looking at your hiring practices and making changes to improve the results. If you don’t have a Kaizen culture, you should, but, just because you have a process, doesn’t mean it is an efficient process. You need to examine that process and then start measuring the results to see where it can be improved.
Direct Costs
-
Hiring Costs
-
Compensation Costs
-
Severance Costs
Indirect Costs
-
Support Costs
-
Cost of Poor Performance
-
Loss of Poor Subordinate / Department Morale
-
Value of Bad image in the Workforce
If you want to determine the cost to you from a bad hire, click here for a model that will help you estimate the costs of a bad hire.
The second reason is the damage to morale among the employees that stay. They might think the person was a good hire, and if they left, the remaining employees might question why they are still around.
So Hiring is a Process
Like so many things in business, hiring is a process. I have heard that if a company establishes a good process and sticks with it, it can move that hiring success rate from 50% to 80-90%. If we stick to the process and work to improve it, we should get better results. If we “wing it” and don’t track the success, then we have no idea what is working and what isn’t or how we are performing.
To avoid keeping bad hires on your team for long, have a strategy in place to continuously hire–especially for roles you know will open up throughout the year. It’ll help you quickly replace bad hires and build a network of talent to staff up as your team grows.
Keep jobs posted on your career site–even if you don’t have an immediate opening. If a strong candidate comes along, you can offer an informational interview. If the meeting goes well, you might even decide to hire the candidate before you have an immediate need. If not, you’ll have a pool of talent to tap into when you need to make an urgent hire, i.e., when you let go of a bad hire or suddenly experience business growth.
Hiring the right employee is much more important than simply filling a seat.
I have identified the hiring steps to be:
The Job Advertisement
From a talk I heard many years ago, I took away that ads, in general, do not attract good people, more like the bottom third. Most job specifications define the minimum standards; basically, we end up with the tallest pigmy. Good people and Millennials want to know what I am going to learn and what is the job going to do for me.
You have to inform candidates of the following:
-
What is the situation or problem?
-
What are the main obstacles the employee will encounter to be successful?
-
What actions need to be taken to accomplish the problem?
-
What are the measurable, quantifiable results required that define success?
Instead, what we state is the following:
-
Such and Such Industry experience
-
XYZ Technical Degree / Certification
-
ABC Skills and knowledge
-
D E & F Behaviors and attitude
-
Minim
um of T Years of experience
If this hasn’t bored you yet, it should have. No “A” player is excited over this! You haven’t sold them. What we should be saying is:
-
Fast-growing company in fast /new/challenging sector
-
Opportunity to part of a successful team to create a market-leading organization
-
Increase sales by X% and improve margins by y% within T months
-
Build an Indep. Rep. Channel in X within Y days
-
Implement sales forecasting and pipeline management with Z months
-
Revamp all sales collateral within Q months.
The Search
Recruiters are expensive, and I hear they are often sending the same people that are responding to ads on Monster and Indeed. Instead, reach out to your network, customers, suppliers, advisers, etc. Provide them a copy of your job description and ask if they know someone who would be interested and who would fit within your culture.
The Sorting
A lot of HR departments have turned to technology to help them with recruitment. They are using scanners to look for words and phrases on a resume that meet their job description. However, given that they are using the failed advertisement, it makes matters worse as it excludes those that would be great hires but don’t fit with what the computer is seeking. Remember, all these algorithms are programmed and have biases, but we don’t always know the preference. Unfortunately, reviewing resumes needs a human eye until computers get much better.
I recently heard a story of someone who was looking for Venture Capital funding. They sent an email to a VC firm that had a video of them singing “Call Me Maybe” with revised wording. The effect worked. The VC was intrigued and asked to meet them. Your automated system will not take these people in and could reject some great possible hires.
The Interviewing
We have all heard of those interview questions to determine how an employee thinks. However, interviewing is more than a few tricky questions, not to say you should give up on them. Consider the interview an audition rather than an interview.
Experience
If you need a welder, get the applicant to do some welding. If you need an Operations manager get them to do a presentation on what they would do to solve the “S” in Soar. If they have to code, make them code something that doesn’t necessarily require the language knowledge but the thinking of how to structure the problem for coding.
Rather than ask them about the experience on their resume, which they have rehearsed, get them to whiteboard the entire project and layout everyone’s role and contribution. If an applicant just had a small part, they will not be able to do it.
Cultural Fit
Cultural fit is talked about continuously but still gets little application. Primarily I would put this down to the fact that many employees don’t know what their culture is. A client of mine recently when around their company, which has 50 employees, and offered each one $100 if they could say what the culture was. Only one employee could, and to my client’s chagrin, printed all over the office, is the corporate culture. The message is only in words and not carried into behaviors.
-
At Zappos, an applicant who is not a local gets a free ride from the airport to Zappos’ Las Vegas headquarters. In addition to being a convenience, it is also a subtle part of the application process. During the rides, the van driver is paying attention to how the applicants carry themselves and treat them, regardless of whether their travel was pleasant or not. After a full day that includes a tour and multiple interviews, a recruiter checks in with the driver to get their impression. Hsieh said in an interview with the Wall Street Journal in 2013, “It doesn’t matter how well the day of interviews went, if our shuttle driver wasn’t treated well, then we won’t hire that person.”
-
Elon Musk, initially, interviewed every employee last to check for cultural fit and asked employees to write a letter saying why they wished to work for SpaceX. Former SpaceX talent director Dolly Singh said that Musk told her to find the single best person on the planet for any given job, no matter the role. When SpaceX built a yogurt stand in its headquarters, Musk instructed her, “Go to Pinkberry and find me the employee of the month.” Musk also looks for candidates with a positive attitude. He also considers whether co-workers would like working with them–what he refers to as a strict “no-assholes policy.” Musk asked her, “what makes you the right person to build my company? Why should I trust you?”
Due to the failings of the interview, some people have started to use unorthodox methods to determine a candidate’s potential, i.e.
-
playing table tennis to discern their level of intensity and risk-taking,
-
have candidates drive the interviewer’s car to gauge their multitasking skills, or
-
explaining why people shouldn’t work for the company to prompts more honest conversations
The Measurement
What about after the interview, how do you compare the candidates? Most people write down whether they liked them or not, and do think they are a good fit, but this loses the focus. I like using a Decision Matrix to select the best candidate. Click here on how to use a Decision Matrix.
What if You Couldn’t Fire
An e-commerce company, Next Jump, promises never to fire anyone. A company that will not fire is forced to hire slowly and very deliberately. Jay Forte says this type of hiring model (whether or not you choose to offer lifetime employment) is something all companies should consider. “When we choose wisely about who we bring into our organizations, we need to be aware we are making a lifetime decision,” he says. “Not everyone fits in the organization. Therefore, initially choosing wisely is critical. Once chosen, it is right to think that employees will spend all of their careers with the organization – this completely changes how we think about our people.”
Why Should I Work for You?
Like them or hate them, millennials are the largest share of the workforce, so we better figure out how to interact with them. Because of the way they look at the jobs, unlike the baby boomers, they will not accept, “You should be happy I am giving you a job.” They saw what happened in the Great Recession and that they are disposable, so their attitude is “I work for you, you offer me something more than money – satisfaction, career advancement, training, etc.”
I have posed the following question to a lot of CEOs, “You have the perfect candidate in front of you interviewing for a job. They have everything you need, skills, experience, cultural fit, and attitude. You are about to make the offer, and they look at you and say, ‘Why should I work for you?’” None of the CEOs have a great answer. I get responses along the lines of:
-
We’re a great company.
-
There are great opportunities for advancement at XYZ.
-
We have a great workforce.
These sound good, but if this person is interviewing with several companies, all the companies are probably saying the same thing. You know none of the other companies are saying:
-
We are an awful company
-
We are offering a dead-end job in a dead-end company
-
The people here are terrible and will never go anywhere because they are so bad.
So how do you distinguish yourself from the pack? You better be able to answer this question well and authentically to get those “A” players.
Onboarding vs. Waterboarding
Over 70 percent of employees regret their decision after the first day of a new job! No one I have ever met has started work at a new company, not excited about the opportunity and the change for a fresh start with upside. If by the end of the day, 70 percent think they made a mistake, that should tell you how fantastic most onboarding processes are. I experienced such a great onboarding experience many years ago as follows:
-
I arrived and sent to HR to fill out reams of paperwork (they could have sent them to my house, and I could have come with them completed).
-
Taken to security to get my badge – took an hour
-
Brought to my desk to find out that my boss was away on business for the week. No one knew what I was supposed to do, but there were four binders on the desk full of information on some prior deals that I was supposed to read.
-
As I was during my “probation period,” my computer could not be connected to the network, so all files were transferred on disks.
-
I was not allowed to order business cards until my probation had ended, even though I was heading to Asia for a large conference the following week.
I was one of the seventy percent, which was thinking, “What the hell have I done, why did I move.”
By the time the probation period is over, the marriage is over, and the employee no longer loves the company. They have checked out.
I believe it was Cameron Herold who said that his philosophy was to celebrate the arrival of a new employee on their first day. The new employee would be asked to bring their Bucket List. The company would commit to helping the employee realize one item on their Bucket List during their first year. Helping didn’t mean paying for it, but rather seeing how the company could make it possible. People value experiences over money, and if you did this for your employees, they would appreciate you much more than any bonus you can give them.
Finally, onboarding doesn’t end on the first day, but it continues for more than the first year with regular check-ins. The check-ins are to:
-
reinforce that the employee knows what you expected of them,
-
they have the resources that they need to do the job;
-
they understand the company’s culture and values and are living them.
Good luck recruiting, and may your success rate increase.
© 2019 Marc Borrelli All Rights Reserved
Recent Posts
EOS is just that, an Operating System
The EOS Model® provides a useful foundation for businesses, but it falls short in addressing key aspects of creating an growth. By incorporating additional elements from the Gravitas 7 Attributes of Agile Growth® model, businesses can create a more comprehensive system that promotes growth while maintaining smooth operations. Focusing on Leadership, Strategy, Execution, Customer, Profit, Systems, and Talent, the 7 Attributes of Agile Growth® offer a more encompassing approach to achieving success.
What has COVID done to Company Culture?
COVID has affected everyone. However, companies need to examine if they have lived their core values during COVID, how they are reinforcing them in a WFH environment, and especially with the onboarding of new hires.
Profit ≠ Cash Flow
Knowing how much cash you generate is essential for planning for growth. Too many companies don’t know and when they grow they find they are continually running out of cash. Understand your cash flow generation and how to improve it through improvements in your Cash Conversion Cycle and using the Power of One.
What Are Your Critical and Counter Critical Numbers?
The key to achieving long term goals is to define short term goals that lead you there. Focusing those short term goals around a key metric is essential. However, ensure that the metric will not lead other areas astray by having an appropriate counter critical metric act as a counter balance.
Rethinking ‘Family’ Culture in Business: Fostering Performance and Success
Explore the importance of company culture and the potential pitfalls of adopting a “Family” culture in organizations. Learn how to foster a high-performance culture while maintaining key family values and discover success factors for family businesses. Rethink the “Family” culture concept and create a thriving environment for your organization.
Do You Truly Know Your Core Customer?
Knowing the profit of your core customers is key to building a growth model. Many companies have identified core customers that are generating a sub-optimal profit and so they cannot realize the profits they seek. Identifying the correct core customer allows you to generate profits and often operate in “Blue Ocean.”
The Spectacular Rise and Fall of the European Super League
The European Super League (ESL) collapsed within 48 hours of its announcement due to hubris, a lack of value creation, and fan backlash. The founders’ arrogance led them to disregard European football’s deep-rooted traditions and culture. At the same time, the focus on wealthy club owners instead of merit undermined the essence of the competition. The fierce backlash from fans, who felt betrayed by their clubs, demonstrated the importance of prioritizing supporters’ interests in football.
When Should I Sell My Business?
Many business owners want to sell at the top of the market. However, market timing is tough. Is this the best strategy? Probably not.
Does Your Financial Model Drive Growth?
Working with many companies looking to grow, I am always surprised how many have not built a financial model that drives growth. I have mentioned before a financial model that drives growth? Here I am basing on Jim Collin's Profit/X, which he laid out in Good to...
COVID = Caught Inside
As we emerge from COVID, the current employment environment makes me think of a surfing concept: “Being Caught Inside When a Big Set Comes Through.” Basically, the phrase refers to when you paddle like crazy to escape the crash of one wave, only to find that the next wave in the set is even bigger—and you’re exhausted. 2020 was the first wave, leaving us tired and low. But looking forward, there are major challenges looming on the horizon as business picks up in 2021. You are already asking a lot of your employees, who are working flat out and dealing with stress until you are able to hire more. But everyone is looking for employees right now, and hiring and retention for your organization is growing more difficult.
Can you be more specific about the content of your article? After reading it, I still have some doubts. Hope you can help me. https://www.binance.info/zh-TC/join?ref=B4EPR6J0
Way cool, some valid points! I appreciate you making this article available, the rest of the site is also high quality. Have a fun.
I cling on to listening to the reports speak about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the top site to get one. Could you advise me please, where could i find some?
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?
I do accept as true with all the concepts you have presented in your post. They are very convincing and will definitely work. Still, the posts are too quick for novices. May just you please extend them a bit from next time? Thank you for the post.
A large percentage of of whatever you say is astonishingly precise and it makes me ponder the reason why I hadn’t looked at this with this light previously. This piece truly did turn the light on for me personally as far as this topic goes. Nevertheless there is one issue I am not really too comfy with so whilst I attempt to reconcile that with the actual core idea of your point, allow me observe exactly what the rest of the visitors have to say.Well done.
You are in reality a good webmaster. The site loading speed is amazing.
It kind of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick.
Furthermore, the contents are masterpiece.
you have performed a great activity in this topic! Similar here: e-commerce and also here:
Najtańszy sklep
Hey there, I think your blog might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your blog site in Safari, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, amazing blog!
Thankyou for this marvellous post, I am glad I observed this web site on yahoo.
Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with SEO?
I’m trying to get my website to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m
not seeing very good results. If you know of any please
share. Thanks! I saw similar text here: Backlink Portfolio
What is Boostaro? Boostaro revolutionizes romantic performance enhancement through its reliance on the wisdom of natural ingredients
great points altogether, you simply won a new reader. What could you recommend in regards to your post that you just made a few days in the past? Any positive?
Hello, you used to write magnificent, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your tremendous writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!
I’m not sure why but this website is loading incredibly slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? I’ll check back later and see if the problem still exists.
Wow, wonderful weblog structure! How lengthy have you ever been running
a blog for? you make blogging look easy. The overall glance
of your website is fantastic, as smartly as the content!
You can see similar here e-commerce
Wow, amazing weblog structure! How long have you ever been running a blog for?
you make running a blog look easy. The overall glance of your web site is magnificent, as smartly as the content!
You can see similar here sklep online
You have observed very interesting details! ps nice web site. “I just wish we knew a little less about his urethra and a little more about his arms sales to Iran.” by Andrew A. Rooney.
Wow, awesome blog format! How long have you ever been blogging for?
you made running a blog glance easy. The entire glance of your web site is
wonderful, as neatly as the content material!
You can see similar here e-commerce
Real instructive and fantastic complex body part of content, now that’s user genial (:.
I got what you intend,saved to fav, very decent site.
What Is Puravive? Before we delve into the various facets of the supplement, let’s start with the most important
Fitspresso stands out among the crowded health supplement market as an exceptional product.
Wow, wonderful blog format! How long have you been running
a blog for? you made blogging look easy. The full glance of
your website is fantastic, as neatly as the content!
I read similar here prev next and it’s was wrote by Rosanne93.
Fitspresso stands out among the crowded health supplement market as an exceptional product.
Good write-up, I am regular visitor of one¦s blog, maintain up the nice operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a long time.
Wow! Thank you! I always wanted to write on my site something like that. Can I take a fragment of your post to my blog?
Wow, wonderful weblog layout! How lengthy have you ever been running a blog for?
you make running a blog glance easy. The overall look of your site
is fantastic, let alone the content! You can see similar
here prev next and those was wrote by Glenn00.
Wow, fantastic blog structure! How long have you been running a
blog for? you made blogging glance easy. The overall look of your website
is fantastic, as neatly as the content! You can see similar here prev next and it’s was wrote by
Tyesha80.
Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch since I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thanks for lunch! “Remember It is 10 times harder to command the ear than to catch the eye.” by Duncan Maxwell Anderson.
Appreciating the time and effort you put into your website and detailed information you provide. It’s awesome to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same unwanted rehashed information. Great read! I’ve saved your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.
I really like your writing style, great info , appreciate it for posting : D.
Wohh just what I was looking for, regards for putting up.