To the shock and horror of many in the business community, top CEOs from the Business Roundtable stated two weeks ago that Shareholder Value is not Everything. These CEOs, including the leaders of Apple and JPMorgan Chase, argued that companies must also invest in employees and deliver value to customers.
The Business Roundtable is trying to redefine the role of business in society — and how an increasingly skeptical public perceives companies. Breaking with decades of the Friedman Doctrine, which holds that a firm’s only responsibility is to its shareholders, the Business Roundtable stated that companies should no longer advance only the interests of shareholders. Instead, companies must also invest in their employees, protect the environment, and deal fairly and ethically with their suppliers.
This shift in corporate ideology comes at a moment of increasing tension in corporate America, as big companies face mounting discontent over income inequality, harmful products, and poor working conditions.
There have been many arguments for and against this stand, i.e., Why Maximizing Shareholder Value Is Finally Dying, Corporations Can Shun Shareholders, But Not Profits, Stakeholder Capitalism Will Fail If It’s Just Talk, and We must Rethink the Purpose of the Corporation.
Personally, however, I think that this is a move in the right direction for the following reasons.
The Friedman Doctrine is backward.
Shareholder value is the result of corporate purpose and Mission and cannot be the purpose and Mission. Simon Senik’s “Start with Why,” in my opinion, best describes how to develop a corporate mission. An example of what happens when a company game up is mission and followed the Friedman Doctrine was Imperial Chemical Industries, who changed its mission from “We aim to be the finest chemical company in the world“ to “We aim to Maximize Shareholder Value“ in the 1990s. Prior to the change, ICI was considered one of the finest companies in Britain, today it no longer exists having been slowly sold off many parts to repay its debt before finally being sold to AkzoNobel in 2008.
Few stakeholders within the organization.
If the maximization of shareholder value is the corporate Mission, then there are few within the organization, other than some high-level employees, who have a stake in the Mission. Working to increase the wealth of others is not something most employees get behind. It reminds me of the old joke:
Employee: “Nice new car, boss”
Boss: “Well, if you set yourself targets, work hard, stay focused, next year I’ll be able to buy an even better one.”
Employees are only attracted to the company with this mission by what they will get, i.e., money or career advancement, so there is little commitment to the organization. If the expected benefits aren’t delivered or someone else offers more money, the employees will move on, increasing employee turnover. As a result, with few employees embracing the Mission and no other purpose, nothing is of importance to quality, service, and profits fall, decreasing brand value and shareholder value. Employees who embrace the Mission and are satisfied will serve customers better, increasing brand value. Employee happiness and business success are linked.
Few stakeholders outside the organization.
If the employees see no value in the Mission, customers and suppliers don’t. If the Mission is only to make money, customers and suppliers understand the Mission as a goal of extracting more value from them. Thus, they move from commitment to the organization (i.e., putting an Apple sticker on your car) to engaging with the company because there is no better alternative. If the company gets into financial trouble, they are less likely to support it, but rather let it fail. Working with suppliers is a relationship with the power moves back and forth and both parties treat it with care knowing they will be on the receiving end at some point. However, if shareholder value maximization is the only goal of the organization, suppliers abandon that relationship knowing the company has in its behavior.
Lack of Investment in Interesting products.
The Friedman Doctrine has led to many companies killing off research centers, which generated great benefits unidentified at the start. Ten years ago, the majority of technology products were offshoots from two places, Xerox Parc and Bell Labs, both of which no longer exist because of the Friedman doctrine. Between share buybacks and dividends, corporate investment in new areas has fallen. Google, SpaceX, and a few other companies have stepped into this space, but it is far more limited, thus limiting the future growth potential for the US.
Lack of Training.
Thirty years ago, when I graduated from college, many companies had training programs which took in graduates and trained them over several years. These programs knew that most of the trainees would leave the organization and thus canceled under the Friedman Doctrine. However, I would argue that these programs had three positive results:
- Well Trained Employees. A common complaint today is that graduates don’t know anything; however, I would say we didn’t know more, but we benefited from such programs.
- Loyalty to the Organization. Employees who moved on had developed a commitment to the organization that had trained them. Over the years they referred work to it and would engage with that company because of the feeling towards it.
- The camaraderie with their fellow trainees. Employees who went through the training program built a camaraderie with their fellow cohorts, which lasted a lifetime. I have met many accountants who came through the training programs provided by Arthur Anderson and still talk about their classmates and the connections they made. This camaraderie further built referral networks that benefited those that stayed behind and the training organization.
Lack of Integrity.
I recently heard Kirk Lippold‘s definition of integrity, which is:
“Integrity defines leadership. Without uncompromising integrity, failure becomes the natural default to success. It’s not just doing the right thing at the right time for the right reasons, even if no one is looking. That’s ethics. Integrity is doing all those ethical things regardless of the consequences.”
If the Mission is to maximize shareholder value, then I believe the organization develops a modus operandi of maximizing profit as the proxy for shareholder value. Since profit is measured monthly and quarterly, the corporate focus becomes more short term and undertakes anything to cut costs and maximize revenue. Thus, companies lose their integrity, sacrificing what makes them special for money, and losing customer loyalty and brand value. Recent examples of this would be Wells Fargo fake accounts scandal, and the Boeing and the 737 Max. An example of long term brand damage is the Sun Newspaper and Liverpool boycott, and many others. For a an example at what lack integrity can do see The Whistleblower (trailer is below) which based on a true story. Thus to quote Timothy 6:10, “For the love of money is the root of all evil.”
An example of a Mission leading shareholder value is Johnson & Johnson’s response at the time of the Tylenol recall. J&J’s Mission is to “. . . solutions that create a better, healthier world.” Living that Mission, created goodwill and tremendous brand loyalty within the US. A company’s brand is its reputation, and damage done takes a very long time to recover, destroying shareholder value.
Therefore, I think that the Business Roundtable is correct; Shareholder Value cannot be the purpose of the organization. If the company focuses on its Mission and engages its employees, customers, and suppliers, increases in shareholder value should result. Shareholder value should be measured, and companies should see how they are doing, but it is one metric and should not be the purpose. Further, in my opinion, the Friedman doctrine has done untold damage to the US over the years. Private Equity Groups, which own over $2.5 trillion of companies globally, primary focus on Shareholder Value has had mixed, if not harmful, results for their investment companies.
© 2019 Marc Borrelli All Rights Reserved
Recent Posts
The Downfall of Boeing: A Lesson in Core Values
Boeing’s 737 Max issues highlighted the company’s sacrifice of safety for financial performance, resulting in a tarnished reputation. The prioritization of profit over core values also damaged the FAA’s credibility and revealed a lack of accountability for top executives. This downfall serves as a reminder of the importance of maintaining core values and prioritizing them over short-term financial gains.
Resolutions, Here We Go Again.
In reflecting on 2021 resolutions, the author scored themselves in three categories and sought to improve success in 2022 by addressing friction points. Drawing on advice from social psychologist Wendy Wood, the author identified areas to reduce or increase friction in their failed resolutions. By making these adjustments, the author aims to enhance their goal achievement and encourages others to consider friction when setting resolutions.
You need to take an extended vacation. No, seriously, you do.
COVID has taken a toll on all of us. If you have not taken an extended vacation in a while where you disconnect, you need to now. You and your business will benefit.
Becoming Famous in Your Niche: The Success Story of Linn Products Limited
In a previous discussion, I highlighted the importance of being famous for something. Being well-known in your niche can help you: Concentrate on your strengths Connect with your target audience Communicate your offerings more effectively Receive referrals Identify...
Understanding and Optimizing Your Cash Conversion Cycle
Understanding and optimizing the Cash Conversion Cycle is crucial for business growth, as it impacts cash flow and the ability to access external capital. This cycle consists of four components: Sales, Make/Production & Inventory, Delivery, and Billing and Payments. To improve the Cash Conversion Cycle, companies can eliminate mistakes, shorten cycle times, and revamp their business models.
Discovering Your Niche: Why You Need to Be Famous for Something
As an entrepreneur, it’s crucial to specialize in a specific area and become famous for something, allowing you to generate referrals and build your brand. Understanding the “job” you’re hired for helps you stand out in the marketplace and communicate your value proposition effectively. By providing value to your clients, you can adopt a value-based pricing approach, ensuring your business remains competitive and maintains a strong market presence.
Rethinking Your Pricing Model: Maximizing Margins and Providing Value
Rethink your pricing model by focusing on the value you provide and your customers’ Best Alternative To a Negotiated Agreement (BATNA). This approach can help you maximize margins while delivering better value to your clients. Assess your offerings and brainstorm with your team to identify pricing adjustment opportunities or eliminate commodity products or services.
Do you know your Profit per X to drive dramatic growth?
I recently facilitated a workshop with several CEOs where we worked on the dramatic business growth model components. One of the questions that I had asked them beforehand was, "What is Your Profit/X?" The results showed that there this concept is not clear to many....
The War for Talent: 5 Ways to Attract the Best Employees
In today’s War for Talent, attracting the best employees requires a focus on value creation, core customer, brand promise, and value delivery. Clearly articulate your company’s mission, identify your “core employee” based on shared values, and offer more than just a salary to stand out as an employer. Utilize employee satisfaction metrics and showcase your company’s commitment to its workforce on your website to make a strong impression on potential candidates.
Are you killing your firm’s WFH productivity?
Productivity remained during WFH with COVID. However, further analysis found that hourly productivity fell and was compensated for by employees working more hours. What was the culprit – Meetings. Want to increase productivity, have fewer meetings.
what is the best time of day to take lisinopril
glucophage chile
glucophage cutting
zithromax side effects children
does gabapentin work right away
lasix dosage for water retention
zithromax alcohol
lasix and kidney disease
gabapentin withdrawal symptoms
what is amoxicillin 500mg used for
does amoxicillin have to be refrigerated
cephalexin 500mg dosage
does escitalopram cause weight gain
side effects from gabapentin
escitalopram tab 10mg
gabapentin after surgery could cause trouble
cephalexin overdose
ciprofloxacin with food
ciprofloxacin dexamethasone ear drops price
what is bactrim used to treat
ciprofloxacin vs cephalexin
is bactrim safe in pregnancy
cephalexin how long to work
amoxicillin and potassium clavulanate
amoxicillin tooth infection
bactrim f para que sirve
cephalexin tooth infection
bactrim dose uti
escitalopram controlled substance
gabapentin migraine
escitalopram oxalate 10 mg oral tablet
neurontin generic name
how long does iv ddavp last
how fast does citalopram work
cozaar walmart price
can cozaar make you tired
depakote 500 mg twice a day
half life ddavp iv
citalopram long term side effects
depakote drug
drugs.com losartan or cozaar?
cozaar medication for blood pressure
ddavp nasal posologia
depakote lawsuit
citalopram side effects weight gain
ddavp nebulizador nasal
citalopram price
how long does it take depakote to reach therapeutic levels
buy augmentin online
augmentin wiki
medications diclofenac
diltiazem drug side effects
ezetimibe uses
diltiazem 120 mg tablet
ezetimibe prostate cancer
diclofenac pill
flomax ibuprofen interaction
flomax vs hytrin
how often can you take flexeril 10mg
contrave quora
effexor xr weight loss
My spouse and I stumbled over here from a different website and thought I might check things out. I like what I see so now i am following you. Look forward to looking at your web page again.
contrave for anxiety
effexor and alcohol
flexeril and oxycodone
can i take amitriptyline with gabapentin
aspirin for blood clots
amitriptyline for ibs
fda approval aripiprazole
allopurinol tab 100mg
aspirin for headaches
allopurinol long term use
aripiprazole onset of action
bupropion how long to take effect
augmentin strep
bupropion hydrobromide
baclofen max dose
celebrex brand name
augmentin mrsa
You are in reality a good webmaster. The web site loading pace is amazing.
It sort of feels that you’re doing any unique trick. Furthermore, the contents are
masterwork. you have done a wonderful task on this topic!
Similar here: silvoria.top and also here: Najlepszy sklep
celebrex generic price
baclofen overdose treatment
Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with
Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my blog to
rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
If you know of any please share. Appreciate it! You can read similar article here: Sklep online
what does buspirone hcl
does buspar work
max dose of celexa
ashwagandha and alcohol
celecoxib medication
celexa social anxiety
ic celecoxib 200 mg
ashwagandha overdose
Thanks for sharing. I read many of your blog posts, cool, your blog is very good.
Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to
assist with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted keywords
but I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
Thanks! You can read similar article here: List
of Backlinks
Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to
get my website to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not
seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
Thanks! I saw similar article here: Backlink Building
acarbose children
is abilify dangerous
abilify deals
actos ahumada
semaglutide 7 mg side effects
indikasi acarbose
actos sulfonylurea
saxenda vs semaglutide
repaglinide solid lipid nanoparticles
protonix side effects mayo clinic
repaglinide emc
is robaxin
remeron for dogs
protonix dr
remeron hair loss
ativan and robaxin
Saved as a favorite, I really like your web site!
sitagliptin how to take
n-nitroso sitagliptin amine
spironolactone 75
synthroid production
synthroid vyvanse
Wow, amazing blog format! How long have you ever been running a blog for?
you make blogging look easy. The whole look of your site is wonderful,
let alone the content! You can see similar here ecommerce
spironolactone 8 mg
ivermectin 3 mg tablet dosage
voltaren tablets
generic voltaren gel coupon
tizanidine 5mg
venlafaxine diarrhea
tamsulosin awp
tizanidine and weight gain
tamsulosin darreichungsform
what is venlafaxine generic for
Wow, awesome weblog structure! How lengthy have you ever
been running a blog for? you make running a
blog look easy. The overall glance of your web site is wonderful,
let alone the content! You can read similar here prev next and those was wrote by Glory09.
zetia 10 mg tablet
zetia 10 mg side effects
zofran codeine
wellbutrin investigation
generic zyprexa
can you od on zofran
is zyprexa a controlled substance
Wow, amazing blog layout! How long have you ever been running a
blog for? you make running a blog glance easy. The total look of your web site is
magnificent, let alone the content! You can see similar
here prev next and it’s was wrote by Charmaine64.
zofran iv push administration
define zyprexa
wellbutrin sr dosage strengths
can zofran cause migraines
zyprexa suit